In the movie I selected, the house bunny, there were many stereotypes that deal with gender or social things. Due to differences in how men and women learn to use language certain class style formats allow some groups advantages over others. The most common format used is the debate like style. This style favors men over women giving men the upper hand more often than not. Deborah Tannen wrote that “yet speaking in a classroom is more congenial to boys’ language experience than to girls’, since it entails putting oneself forward in front of a large group of people, many of whom are strangers and at least one of whom is sure to judge speakers’ knowledge and intelligence by their verbal display”. Women often end up taking a back seat to men in class room discussions due to the style. Deborah Tannen also mentioned that women tend to be more expressive when the class is split into smaller sections. There are a few exceptions to this however, I myself speak out on a more frequent basis when the class is split into smaller sections, Kristen who sits next to me however does very well in larger debate like style settings, we are both opposite to the general rule that Deborah Tannen claims.
Midway through the movie there was a scene after shelly went on a date. She was sad because it didn’t go well and was having a conversation about it with the zeta’s. shelly is portrayed as an “attractive dumb blonde”. her usual way of doing things is to just be flirty and laugh at everything and let her looks do the rest. The man she was on a date with was more interested in her personality so it didn’t really work. When she asked why her it didn’t go well, Natalie, one of the girls said, maybe he’s one of those guys that like to know a girl first? Shelly’s response was to immediately yell HE’S GAY? Later in the scene shelly borrows Natalie’s glasses and dresses completely different from how she usually dresses. Shelly goes over the top in trying to impress Oliver trying to be something she is not. She tries to speak in a more educated manner compared to her usual manner of speaking. Oliver her date can she is acting strange and asks if she is ok. Shelly ends up tripping because she is wearing glasses that aren’t meant for her, she makes a huge mess tripping and embarrassing herself. There were actually 2 stereotypes in this scene. The obvious one was the “attractive dumb blonde”, the second one is less noticeable, this second stereotype is that all men are superficial and only care about getting laid. Neither of these stereotypes are true yet they are always used in movies and these movies continue to do well at the box office. What does it say about us as a whole if we go to the movies to see movies filled with stereotypes, do we believe them? Are they like tall tales which hold a little grain of truth or are they just completely false?
The topic on how female students are less verbal than male students is true only half of the time. Agreeing with you Kristen does well, and likes to have her voice heard. But then again this is a much smaller classroom setting. Would she still be as talkative if we were all put in a classroom of 150? Either way I think it just depends on the person itself. Some women are very outspoken and some are very reserved.
ReplyDeleteFernando your analysis was very interactive and I was ale to easily relate to it. Your questions at the end are very good and got me thinking about what our society is like. Why do we constantly go see these kind of movies if they are all about stereotypes. I believe that your title is a little misleading to you post though. Overall good post.
ReplyDeleteFirstly, I like how you made a counterargument about Tannen's claims. I do believe that some of her claims about men are true for women also. I also liked how described your movie scene with great details. You made a great connection with how stereotypes are portrayed in movies versus how well they do at the box office. Your last two questions give a greater insight of your audience. It allows the audience to question themselves whether they believe in stereotypes present in films.
ReplyDeleteI like how detailed you were when describing the movie. I also like how easily you relate to the readers. The only bad thing is that I think the title is a bit misleading.
ReplyDeleteI like how you went so in depth about the particular movie scenes. Blonde girls being dumb is another major stereotype dealing with not just college students but everybody. I like the questions you presented at the end of your blog.
ReplyDelete